# How do I challenge a Solution?

Checked 2026-11-15 against GilbApp d5296208bbffa2ab70076e6194f5537c4be1ddf7.

Press "Main menu", choose "Choose an agent", choose "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning", type that it should sharpen the Solution, and press "Send".

## Before you start

[A project Kai-Zen set up for you](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-start-my-first-plan), with the Solution in its plan, and your own AI, Claude Code or Grok, [connected in GilbApp's chat](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-connect-my-ai-to-gilbapp-chat). The pictures show a made-up person on a test site; your screen shows your own name and address.

## Steps

1. Press "Main menu" at the top left and choose "Choose an agent".

   Press "Main menu", next to your profile picture at the top left, and under "FOR YOU" choose "Choose an agent" \("Pick or connect an AI agent."\). The button shows the name of the section you are in, such as "Vaults". GilbApp opens the left pane, where you chat, and puts the cursor on the agent list at the top of it.

   The square button at the far left of the top bar also shows or hides the left pane. You can also search for "Choose an agent" in "Search or run a command".

   ![GilbApp with the "GO TO" panel open; "Choose an agent" under "FOR YOU" is outlined in orange.](http://support.gilb.com/help/media/0d812ed063f01208.png)
   What you see: The "GO TO" panel is open. In the right column under "FOR YOU", the outlined row is "Choose an agent", with the line "Pick or connect an AI agent." Press it; the chat opens in a pane on the left.
2. Choose "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning" in the agent list.

   Press the agent list at the top of the left pane and choose "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning". Each agent has its own chat, and the list shows which one you are in.

   A new chat starts on the first agent in the list, "Jackfruit - Master Agent of Vaults and Information". The list comes from GilbPlatform each time the chat opens. GilbApp keeps your choice for this browser tab. While an agent is answering, the list is greyed out.

   ![GilbApp with the chat open in the left pane; the agent list at its top, showing "Jackfruit - Master Agent of Vaults and Information", is outlined in orange. The picture shows "Connect" beside it; your screen shows your connected AI.](http://support.gilb.com/help/media/5ce1b91898e1907f.png)
   What you see: The chat pane is open on the left. At its top is the outlined agent list, showing "Jackfruit - Master Agent of Vaults and Information". Open it and choose "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning". Beside the list, the picture shows "Connect"; your screen shows your connected AI there.
3. Type the Solution to sharpen in "Write a message…" and press "Send".

   In "Write a message…", name the project's vault and the Solution's tag \(its short name\), type that Kai-Zen should sharpen that Solution, and press "Send". A Solution is how a Function \(what a system does\) gets done; sharpening it includes challenging it twice: each time Kai-Zen weighs it against one alternative and keeps the winner.

   Return also sends; Shift and Return starts a new line. To sharpen the whole plan, say so instead of naming one Solution: Kai-Zen then challenges every Solution in it. If you do not say where the project is kept, Kai-Zen looks for it in the vaults you can reach; if several fit, it asks which one. While it works, the pane says "The agent is writing…", then "Ran" and the name of each tool it uses, and "Send" reads "Queue". At the end it asks for one approval of the whole result; [the answer on answering Kai-Zen's questions](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-answer-kai-zens-questions) shows how to reply. For example:
   Project in vault gardenclub: sharpen the Solution Save.LocalFirst.

   ![GilbApp with Kai-Zen chosen in the chat and a request to sharpen a Solution typed in the box at the bottom; "Send" to the right of it is outlined in orange. The picture shows "Connect" where your connected AI shows.](http://support.gilb.com/help/media/473c27a597d87b1f.png)
   What you see: "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning" is chosen at the top of the chat pane. In the box at the bottom, a request is typed: the project's vault and "sharpen the Solution Save.LocalFirst." Press the outlined "Send" button to the right of the box.

## Deeper

Also asked:

How do I question a Solution? Ask Kai-Zen to sharpen it: in "Choose an agent", choose "Kai-Zen - Master Agent of Planning", name the Solution and press "Send". Kai-Zen finds one other way of doing it and keeps whichever gives more Value for its cost.

You need not always ask. Kai-Zen sharpens a new project's plan after it has written its levels, sharpens it again with what was learned after each round of delivery, and sharpens it after you add or change a spec, a requirement written in your plan.

Sharpening starts by going up the plan, one item at a time. For each Solution, Kai-Zen asks whether the plan has the right Product Values to judge how good it is; for each Product Value, whether the plan has the right Stakeholder Values to judge how well it performs; and for each Stakeholder Value, the right Business Values. These are the Values at the "Product", "Stakeholder" and "Business" levels of the plan \([the answer on the levels of a plan](http://support.gilb.com/help/what-are-the-levels-of-a-plan)\); a Value is a perceived benefit, measured as a number. Where one is missing, Kai-Zen sharpens a Value or adds one. Values you set yourself it keeps as they are, and lists them for your approval at the end.

Then it goes down from "Business", one item at a time. For each Value it asks whether the Values below deliver to it, and whether it meets its "Goal" \(the number you plan to reach\) when every Value below meets theirs; where not, it adds or changes the Values below. For each Product Value it asks whether the plan has the right Solutions to meet it, and adds the missing ones or changes them. Then it works out each Value Decision Table \(VDT\) again with what changed: a VDT ranks options by how much they move the level's Values for their cost.

Then Kai-Zen challenges every Solution, one at a time, after reading the VDTs already stored. For each Solution it finds one alternative, a completely different way of doing it or a variation of it, and scores the pair against the Product Values in a Value Kick-out Table \(VKT\), which picks one of several options. An option that leaves a Value below its "Tolerable" \(the survival limit\), or breaks a constraint, something that must be done because a named person requires it, is out; the best ratio of Value to cost among the rest wins. Kai-Zen makes its own estimates, costs included, if none are given. It keeps the winner and drops the loser from the choice without asking you and without offering it again, and writes one line in the work's log: the choice, the winner and its ratio; in the chat, that line ends its answer. Ending a record, though, is one of the acts Kai-Zen always stops and asks you about first.

A Solution you chose yourself, in so many words, counts as a constraint: the VKT does not remove it, even when its alternative wins. Kai-Zen lists it for your approval at the end instead.

Then Kai-Zen challenges every Solution once more, the winners of the first round too, each against a new alternative: a different way, an adjustment or a variation. It keeps the winner and drops the loser from the choice again, then works out the VDT from "Product" to the Solutions again with the Solutions that are left; [the answer on comparing Solutions in a VDT](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-compare-solutions-in-a-vdt) shows such a table. Before it ends, it scores again every cell of a stored VDT whose Value or Solution changed, and checks that no cell is empty, that each Value has a "Status" \(where it stands now\), a "Tolerable" and a "Goal", and that each card has a level \(the part of the plan it belongs to\).

You can also challenge a Solution yourself in GilbApp: write the alternative as a second Solution, as [the answer on writing a Solution in your plan](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-write-a-solution-in-my-plan) shows, and compare the two in a VKT, as [the answer on choosing between options with a VKT](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-choose-between-options-with-a-vkt) shows. GilbApp has no control that challenges a Solution by itself.

From GilbApp's chat Kai-Zen works only with the vault, unless you choose a code folder while Claude Code is connected; otherwise a project kept in a folder on your computer needs Claude Code in Terminal. The answer [How do I let my AI build in a folder on my computer from GilbApp's chat?](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-let-my-ai-build-in-a-folder-on-my-computer-from-gilbapps-chat) shows how. In Claude Code in Terminal you can continue a project the same way. Start Claude Code, type this line with your own short name, the one you gave your AI when you [connected your computer](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-connect-my-computer-to-my-vault), and press Return:
/mcp\_\_gilb-&lt;short name\>\_\_agent
Then say which project and which Solution to sharpen, and press Return.

This answer is written for a computer screen.

Source: GilbApp af0f04ee838a4d55887d2ff1f72edd49a4ff7ca0 \(https://gilb.com/app/version.json read 2026-11-09, buildTime 2026-11-09.522Z, dirty false\); code read at af0f04ee \(no checkout\). screen words re-read at af0f04ee: sectionMenuList.ts:330 \("Choose an agent", "Pick or connect an AI agent."\), LeftRegion.tsx:16-20 \(opens the left pane, focuses the agent list\), AgentSelector.tsx:15-16 \(option text "&lt;name\> - &lt;description\>"\), :57-79 \(list; disabled while busy\), chatAgents.ts:67-75 \(choice kept for the tab\). Production agent list https://gilb.com/base/ai/agents read 2026-11-09: picks Jackfruit "Master Agent of Vaults and Information", Kai-Zen "Master Agent of Planning", Agent.Concept, Agent.Coder. Step 3: AgentChat.tsx:1046 \("Write a message…"\), :1063 \("Send"/"Queue"\), :711 \(Return sends unless Shift\), :545 and :888 \("The agent is writing…"\). No challenge or sharpen control in GilbApp: the code shows only sign-in and computer-key code \(webauthn challenge\). Standards \(2026-11-09, all 200\): Kai-Zen.Sharpen \(Entry.Specs "the project's specs, or the part to sharpen"; Up; Down; Challenge; Repeat; Exit\), Kai-Zen.New step Sharpen \(after Down\), Kai-Zen.Cycle step Improve \("Sharpen the specs with what was learned"\), Kai-Zen.Existing steps Read, Evaluate \("re-plan or sharpen"\), Change \(then sharpen\), Replan \("IF it asks to re-plan or to sharpen → sharpen"\), Kai-Zen.VKT \(Ends, Options, Table, Execute, Log "In a chat, put that line at the end of your answer"\), Kai-Zen.VKTRules \(Alternatives, TolerableFirst, NoHuman, Estimate, HumanSet, Constraints\), Kai-Zen.ConstraintRules.Options, Kai-Zen.AskRules \(Stop: ending a record always stops that part; EndApproval\), Jackfruit.End \("End a record only when the person asks for that record"\), Agent.Architect \(Sharpen hands each Solution to it\). GilbVeda public read 2026-11-09: t:ValueKickOutTable \("chooses exactly one of several alternative options"\), t:ValueDecisionTable. Shift and Return starts a new line." and "ending a record". Code-folder exception: GilbApp 49b1ae53 \(https://gilb.com/app/version.json, read 13 November 2026\), src/components/agent/AgentChat.tsx:677-692 and :1084-1090 \("Choose a code folder", "Code in", Claude Code only\); live answer How do I let my AI build in a folder on my computer from GilbApp's chat?
