Two of us changed the same record at the same time. Whose change is kept?
Short answer
In the plan the first save is kept and the second is told; on most other records, such as a note, the last save wins.
Before you start
Words used here (1)
- record
- A record is one piece of data with its own address, such as a person, a place, a thing or a note.
Deeper
Several people can work in the vault at the same time. Whose change is kept depends on the record and on what you both changed.
On a card in the plan and on a person's or an organisation's card, GilbApp checks before it saves. If someone else saved a change to the same field first, their change is kept, and the person who saves second sees a message such as "This record changed elsewhere. The latest is shown; your change to a field that was also changed there was not saved." or, on a card in the plan, "This changed elsewhere. The card now shows the latest; your change was not saved." Your changes to other fields are saved. If your change is still needed, make it again.
A number another person set in the plan, such as one under Impacts, is not replaced without asking: before you replace it, GilbApp asks Replace it with yours? after their name, with Replace and Keep theirs. Keep theirs writes nothing.
On a person's or an organisation's card, GilbApp reads the card again and adds your changes to it, so a line the other person added there is kept too.
Changing what kind of record something is, with the type list, is checked on every record: if the record changed elsewhere meanwhile, nothing is written, the card shows the record as stored and you choose the type again.
The box under NOTES in a vault's panel in Vaults, which shows What is this vault about? while it is empty, keeps the change saved first: the person who saves second sees "This note changed elsewhere. Your last change was not saved. This is the current note."
On most other records, such as a record of the type Note, GilbApp does not check when you change a field: each save sends every field the card shows, so the save that reaches the vault last is kept. If your card still showed the old text in a field the other person had changed, your save puts that old text back. GilbApp does not check some other changes either, such as a process step or a sharing change, and the later change stays. So agree who works on which record.
If two saves reach GilbPlatform at the very same moment, it refuses one of them, and that one writes nothing.
No change is lost from the record's history once it is saved. GilbPlatform never writes over a fact: a change closes the old fact and adds the new one. GilbPlatform keeps every earlier version of a record, with when each fact, one value in one field, was written and who wrote it. GilbApp has no screen for that history today: ▸ DETAILS on a record shows when it last changed, not who changed it. Programs can read the history; the answer on seeing a record as it was before says more. A change that was not saved is not in the history.
This answer is written for a computer screen.
Source: GilbApp 49467c2b (https://gilb.com/app/version.json, read 14 November 2026): src/components/records/RecordDetail.tsx:1200-1257 (a refused save re-reads the record and keeps the stored value of a field both changed; "This record changed elsewhere. The latest is shown; your change to a field that was also changed there was not saved." :1235), src/lib/base/savedElsewhere.ts (rebaseOnStored), src/lib/base/recordHooks.ts (useUpdateRecord: a Plan record's save is checked; other records are saved without the check), RecordDetail.tsx:392-415 (editorFacts: every field the card shows); src/components/records/PlanStakeholders.tsx:72, PlanTagLinks.tsx:177, PlanFunctionForm.tsx:144 (This changed elsewhere. The card now shows the latest …); src/components/records/PlanHumanSet.tsx:233-280 (Replace it with yours?, Replace, Keep theirs); src/components/records/ContactRows.tsx:121-123, :160-165 (a person's card re-read and merged; lines added elsewhere kept); src/components/VaultNoteField.tsx:20-22, :294-299 (Notes, drawn in capitals; What is this vault about?), src/components/VaultDetail.tsx:457 ("This note changed elsewhere. Your last change was not saved. This is the current note."). GilbPlatform 0fc5a548 (https://id.gilb.com/version, read 14 November 2026): src/server/app.ts:236-244 (write_conflict: nothing was written). Live help pages, sentences shared: Can several people work on the same project?; How do I write only if nothing changed (If-Match)? (which GilbApp changes are checked); How do I see a record as it was before (its history)?
Checked against GilbApp d529620.