# Why does my plan need Solutions, and who chooses them?

Checked 2026-11-15 against GilbApp d5296208bbffa2ab70076e6194f5537c4be1ddf7.

Your plan needs Solutions because they are the ways your app gets built; Kai-Zen's agents choose them, and you approve or change them.

## Deeper

Also asked:

Who decides which Solution is chosen: me or the AI? Kai-Zen and the agents it hands the work to choose the Solutions, and [you approve or change them](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-approve-the-plan-or-say-what-to-change) before any building starts. A way of building you chose yourself is kept and listed for your approval.

What does "Solution" mean in my plan? A Solution is a way to build something: the design that makes a Function, something your app must do, work and makes its Values better, such as a calendar where a customer picks a free time.

A Solution is how your app will do something: the way one of its jobs gets done. In your plan, a Function is something your app must do, such as taking a booking. A Value is a goal for how well your app must do something, such as how quickly a customer can book; the number can come later. A Solution is a way to build something: the design that makes a Function work and makes its Values better.

Why your app needs them: without Solutions, the plan says what the app must do and how good it must be, but not how it will be built. The Solutions are what gets built: each step of the plan, a small piece of the app built and put live in one short round, delivers Solutions or parts of them. Each Solution also says how far it is expected to move each Value and what it is expected to cost, marked as an estimate until it is measured, so different ways can be weighed before anything is built.

A made-up example: a booking app for a small bike-repair shop. A Function: customers book a repair time. A Value: how many minutes it takes a customer to book. Two possible Solutions: a calendar where the customer picks a free time, or a form where the customer asks for a time and the shop answers. Each is weighed by how much faster it makes booking and what it costs to build, and the better one goes into the plan.

Who chooses: Kai-Zen, the planning agent, and the agents it hands the work to. An agent is your AI following one written procedure, its standing instructions, for one kind of work. You do not have to think the Solutions up. They first look for one with the same meaning that already exists, in the project or in GilbPlatform's store of code to reuse, and reuse it rather than write a second one. They weigh the possible Solutions by how far each moves your Values for its cost, and keep the set that first brings every Value up to the lowest level you can accept, then toward its goal, within the budget. Then they challenge each Solution twice against another way of doing it, and keep the better one.

Do you approve them? Yes. Before any building starts, Kai-Zen shows you the whole plan for one approval: the Solutions with the rest of the plan, the steps it suggests with what each should bring and cost, [every assumption](http://support.gilb.com/help/what-is-an-assumption), and every open point. Reply with what you want changed; it changes it and asks once more. Kai-Zen skips this approval only if you said in your own words that you need none.

If you want the app built a certain way, say so in your first message or at the approval. A choice you make yourself is kept: when Kai-Zen challenges the Solutions it may not remove yours, and it lists it for your approval instead. A Solution that must be used because a named person requires it is a "Solution Constraint". Kai-Zen avoids these where it can, because each one rules out many other ways.

Solutions are not fixed. After each step is delivered, Kai-Zen makes the plan more exact with what was learned, and may add, change or replace Solutions then. To change one yourself, tell Kai-Zen in the chat, or change its card in GilbApp's "Plan". The answer [How do I write a Solution in my plan?](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-write-a-solution-in-my-plan) shows the card, and the answer [How do I challenge a Solution?](http://support.gilb.com/help/how-do-i-challenge-a-solution) shows how a Solution is tested against another way.

This answer is written for a computer screen.

Source: Standards: Kai-Zen.SolutionRules \(How, Lookup, Impacts\); Kai-Zen.New \(Down, Show, Cycle\); Kai-Zen's comparison process, https://kaizen.gilb.com/base/e/06gdh7fvsxr9n1751r7ph306zc \(Question, Analyse\); Kai-Zen.Sharpen \(Down, Challenge, Repeat\); Kai-Zen.ConstraintRules \(MustDo, Avoid\); Kai-Zen.AskRules \(Decide, EndApproval\); Kai-Zen.Cycle.Improve; Agent.Coder.Solutions. GilbApp 96968de7, src/shell/gilbAppMenuRows.ts:162 \("Plan"\). Live answers: "What is a Solution?", "How do I write a Solution in my plan?", "How do I challenge a Solution?", "Can I trust what the AI suggests and builds?", "How big should my first version be?".
